The first grain-carrying ship to set sail from Ukraine since the Russian invasion is stranded off the coast of Turkey after the initial buyer of the cargo refused delivery, according to the UN body supervising the reopening of the Black Sea route.
The setback underlines the difficulties of restarting grain shipments and easing a global food crisis sparked by Russia’s naval blockade of Ukraine’s Black Sea ports. The Razoni, loaded with 26,000 tonnes of corn, was the first ship to test the reopening of the route last week after a deal was signed between Ukraine and Russia.
The Razoni is “anchored off the southern Turkish coast and waiting for instructions for the new destination” while its cargo is being resold, according to the UN-led committee overseeing the Russia-Ukraine grain deal.
The vessel’s shipping agent in Tripoli said the initial buyer of the cargo in Lebanon rejected the grain over quality concerns. Another agent, based in Turkey, was waiting for instructions for the cargo, he said, adding: “We don’t know what will happen.” The agents did not disclose who owned the cargo.
The UN has stressed that it is common for cargoes to change hands while en route. However, the failure of the closely watched vessel to complete its journey demonstrates the challenges international organisations and grain traders face in trying to alleviate the growing food crisis and normalise trading in commodities markets.
The rejection of the Razoni’s cargo also raises questions over the condition of the grain which had been loaded on in Ukrainian ports when Russia started its invasion of Ukraine in February.
The UN-led Joint Coordination Centre said its inspectors checked whether the vessel, which left Odesa on August 1, had any unauthorised crew or cargo on board. “We are not involved in conducting food inspection. This is not part of the agreement,” it said.
A total 12 vessels carrying more than 370,000 tonnes of food commodities, including corn, sunflower meal and oil, have left the Ukrainian ports of Odesa, Chornomorsk and Pivdennyi.
None of the ships are covered by the Lloyd’s consortium that agreed to cover the cargo on the vessels operating under the UN-brokered agreement, although insurers believe they have some liability cover. The ships have been keenly watched by insurance companies to assess whether coverage of further exports is viable.
“Details about quality control are understandably vague but the Razoni’s cargo was rejected by the buyer in Lebanon so there will likely be some further problems, particularly on the older grain, which should be seen as distressed cargo,” said Neil Roberts, head of marine and aviation at the Lloyd’s Market Association. “For now, the good news is that some vessels are out and some grain export has resumed, but much remains in the balance.”
While the aim of the grain corridor agreement is to reduce food insecurity and prevent global hunger by facilitating exports of Ukrainian grain and fertiliser, the JCC said it was prioritising the departure of vessels that were ready to leave to free space for inbound vessels and clear grain silos.
Two vessels have arrived in Ukrainian waters this week, although there are no others scheduled at this point, according to shipping platform Sea.
The JCC said it was too early to assess the impact on global food markets of the reopening of the Black Sea. When operations are full and running, exports could reach 2mn to 5mn tonnes for the duration of the initiative, which runs for 120 days, it said.
“All parties at the JCC have recognised that this is a humanitarian initiative and they are working towards that goal,” it said. “At the same time, though, we will not be able to control the commercial world.”
