The U.S.-South Africa relationship has faced increasing strain due to geopolitical tensions, ideological differences, and specific policy disputes. Key factors contributing to this deterioration include:
-
Geopolitical and Policy Disputes: South Africa’s non-alignment in global conflicts, such as its refusal to support UN resolutions condemning Russia’s actions in Ukraine and its filing of a genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice in December 2023, have irritated U.S. policymakers. These actions have led to calls from some U.S. lawmakers to reconsider SouthAfrica’s participation in AGOA.
-
Trump Administration Policies: Since early 2025, the Trump administration has taken a hardline stance, including suspending military assistance to the South African National Defence Force and cutting financial aid, citing South Africa’s policies toward its Afrikaner community and its foreign policy positions. These moves signal a broader shift away from cooperative engagement.
-
Trade Tensions: The imposition of tariffs by the Trump administration in April 2025, described as a “discounted reciprocal” tariff regime, has further strained trade relations. These tariffs have raised concerns about South Africa’s ability to maintain duty-free access to the U.S. market under AGOA.
Status of Agricultural Trade Relations
Agricultural trade is a critical component of South Africa’s exports to the U.S., with products like wine, citrus, and other commodities benefiting from AGOA’s duty-free provisions. However, the deteriorating relationship has not led to a restoration of agricultural trade relations to their previous state:
-
Impact on Agriculture: South Africa is the largest African exporter to the U.S., with approximately 46% of its exports to the U.S. in 2024 covered by AGOA, including significant agricultural products. The potential loss of AGOA benefits threatens up to 200,000 jobs, particularly in agriculture and the automotive sector, with smaller manufacturers of agricultural products and component parts being especially vulnerable.
-
Recent Developments: As of April 2025, key South African exports, including agricultural products, have faced challenges due to the loss of duty-free access under AGOA. Posts on X indicate that South African exports suffered in April 2025, the first month without AGOA benefits, suggesting that trade disruptions are already impacting the agricultural sector.
-
No Restoration in Sight: There is no evidence that agricultural trade relations have been restored. Instead, the imposition of tariffs and the looming expiration of AGOA in September 2025 have heightened uncertainty. South Africa’s agricultural sector faces significant risks if AGOA is not renewed or if the country is excluded due to political tensions.
AGOA’s Status in 2025
The African Growth and Opportunity Act, enacted in 2000 and extended in 2015 to run through September 2025, provides duty-free access to the U.S. market for over 1,800 products from eligible sub-Saharan African countries, including South Africa. Its future is uncertain due to the deteriorating U.S.-South Africa relationship and broader shifts in U.S. trade policy:
-
Expiration and Renewal Prospects: AGOA is set to expire on September 30, 2025, and the Trump administration’s tariff policies and skepticism toward free trade agreements have diminished hopes for its renewal. Analysts suggest that the chances of AGOA being extended are “narrow and windy,” with some congressional aides indicating that businesses should assume the program will lapse.
-
South Africa’s Potential Exclusion: There is a significant risk that South Africa could be excluded from AGOA even if the program is renewed, due to political tensions and U.S. perceptions of South Africa’s foreign policy as anti-American. Some U.S. lawmakers have pushed for South Africa’s removal, citing its alignment with BRICS countries and its stance on global issues.
-
Proposed Extensions: Prior to the current tensions, there were proposals in 2023 to extend AGOA, including a bill by Senator John Kennedy to extend it to 2045 and another by Senator Chris Coons for a 16-year extension to 2041. However, these proposals have not gained traction under the current administration, and the new tariff regime has further complicated renewal discussions.
-
Shift to Alternative Trade Frameworks: Some analysts argue that the U.S. should shift focus from AGOA to supporting the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) to foster intra-African trade and reduce dependence on U.S. markets. This could provide South Africa with alternative trade opportunities but would not immediately offset the loss of AGOA benefits for agriculture.
Broader Context and Implications
-
Economic Impact: While AGOA accounts for only 3-4% of South Africa’s total exports, its benefits are concentrated in key sectors like agriculture and automotive manufacturing. The loss of duty-free access could lead to significant job losses and economic disruption, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises in agriculture.
-
Diversification Efforts: South Africa is encouraged to diversify its trade partners, particularly within Africa and Asia, to reduce reliance on the U.S. market. However, this shift will take time and may not fully mitigate the immediate impact on agriculture if AGOA lapses.
-
Geopolitical Leverage: South Africa’s reserves of critical minerals, vital for the global green transition, give it some leverage in trade negotiations. However, the current U.S. administration’s transactional approach to trade, favoring bilateral agreements over multilateral programs like AGOA, complicates the outlook.
The agricultural trade relationship between South Africa and the U.S. has not been restored and remains under significant strain due to broader diplomatic and geopolitical tensions. The African Growth and Opportunity Act is unlikely to remain in place in its current form beyond September 2025, with South Africa facing a high risk of exclusion due to political disputes. The imposition of tariffs in April 2025 and the lack of progress on AGOA renewal discussions suggest that the agricultural sector will continue to face challenges, with potential job losses and reduced export competitiveness. South Africa’s best course of action may involve prioritizing negotiations to preserve AGOA benefits while accelerating efforts to diversify trade partnerships.
Since early 2025, the relationship between South Africa and the United States has deteriorated, driven by ideological clashes and controversial policies under President Cyril Ramaphosa’s administration. The Economic Freedom Fighters’ (EFF) continued performance of the song “Kill the Boer,” perceived as inflammatory by critics, has fueled tensions, particularly with the U.S., where lawmakers view it as endorsing violence against South Africa’s Afrikaner community. Coupled with ongoing discussions around land expropriation without compensation, these actions have drawn sharp criticism from Washington, with some U.S. officials accusing South Africa of destabilizing policies.
South Africa’s foreign policy further complicates matters. Its acceptance of financial support from Iran and its legal action against Israel at the International Court of Justice in 2023 have positioned it at odds with U.S. interests. These moves, alongside South Africa’s non-alignment in global conflicts like Ukraine, have led to perceptions of an anti-American stance. The Trump administration’s response has been swift, with tariffs imposed in April 2025 and military aid suspended, signaling a broader retreat from cooperation.
The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), set to expire in September 2025, hangs in the balance. South Africa, a major beneficiary of AGOA’s duty-free access for agricultural exports, risks exclusion as U.S. lawmakers question its eligibility. Posts on X highlight the economic toll, with South African exports, including citrus and wine, already suffering from lost AGOA benefits. Without a shift in policy or diplomacy, the “vibe” between the U.S. and South Africa will remain sour, threatening trade and economic stability.
DISCLAIMER
The views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of any entities they represent. The information contained in this website is for general information purposes only. The information is provided by CRA and while we endeavour to keep the information up to date and correct, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the website for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.
